How Bladder Cancer Patients Should Navigate the BCG Shortage

Public Health

How Bladder Cancer Patients Should Navigate the BCG Shortage

“It’s all made from the same manufacturer and the delivery of BCG is not variable. It’s not going to be better for you if given by this particular facility versus another facility. That’s good.”

Unlike many current shortages of supply, the one involving bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) predates the coronavirus pandemic.

BCG, a weakened form of bacteria, is a treatment for non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC). It is administered intravesically through a catheter placed into the bladder. Clinical trials have found it to be more effective than chemotherapy in the treatment of bladder cancer.

Since 2017, Merck has been the sole supplier of BCG for the United States and Canada.

On a recent episode of Bladder Cancer Matters, the official podcast of the Bladder Cancer Advocacy Network, Dr. Robert Svatek, professor and chair of urology at the University of Texas Health San Antonio, discussed what options bladder cancer patients have if BCG is unavailable.  

“The most important thing is to have a discussion with your urologist as a first step to see how important is it that you get BCG. Because while there are multiple different types of patients that would benefit from BCG, some need it more than others,” Svatek said. “There are certain patients where there are other options that are suitable.”

He recommended patients explore local alternatives. Just because the treatment is unavailable at one facility does not mean it cannot be found anywhere in the region.

“It’s good to know that the BCG is the same in terms of its quality, whether you get it in city A or city B,” Svatek said. “It’s all made from the same manufacturer and the delivery of BCG is not variable. It’s not going to be better for you if given by this particular facility versus another facility. That’s good.”

If a limited supply is available, urologists may safely offer a reduced dose of the drug — a technique known as “split dosing,” according to Svatek. The American Urological Association published guidelines for urologists on how to manage and how to maintain high quality of care for patients with NMIBC when a BCG shortage exists.

In certain situations, one center with enough BCG supply for its demand may transfer a portion to another in need, though Svatek said that may not always be an option.

“If I have a limited amount for my patients, it’s going to be difficult for me to transfer it out to another city,” he said. “We’re in this situation where we’re all advocating for our own patients and that’s a difficulty.”

Initial BCG treatments, known as induction treatments, are more critical than doses administered in later phases, or maintenance therapy, Svatek said. He prioritizes it for induction therapy with his own patients.

“Depending on the high-risk features that you have, I might recommend an alternative to maintenance BCG, such as intravesical chemotherapy with things such as gemcitabine, docetaxel, epirubicin, mitomycin, valrubicin,” Svatek said. “These may be used sequentially or in combination as alternative maintenance regimens. And that may be something that you would be interested in and it would be in consultation with the urologist.”

More Urology Articles
Why You Don't Know What Burnout Is 'Until It Hits You in the Face'
Public Health
Medicine’s culture of perfection leaves physicians susceptible to burnout and depression, a urologic oncology surgeon and life coach says on the Speaking of Urology podcast.
Why Problems with Reprocessing Ureteroscopes ‘Haven’t Gone Away’
Prevention Challenges
In a new webinar, Cori Ofstead tallies the new medical device reports on flexible ureteroscopes filed with the FDA since last spring and suggests quality management programs worth implementing for reprocessing.
More From Single-Use Endoscopy
FDA Issues Recall on Disposable Duodenoscope Endcaps

Public Health

After issuing a series of warning letters to Olympus, the FDA has issued a recall on a certain model of single-use distal covers for duodenoscopes.

Gender wage gaps persist in otolaryngology, but there has been progress.

Public Health

But parity remains a long way off — gender lag, for example, contributes to the wage gap since higher proportions of women are now in training and in earlier stages of their careers.

DDW 2023: Case Study Links Single-Use Gastroscopes to Increased Revenue, Other Benefits

Analyzing Value

As the landscape of esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD) and bariatric surgery evolves, it will become even more important for facilities to evaluate the true cost per use.