Graph image

Supply Costs

Study: Sterile Single-Use Bronchoscopes Less Costly than Reusable Bronchoscopes

Hospitals that disinfect and reuse bronchoscopes pay anywhere from 21 percent to 155 percent more per instrument than if they had purchased a sterile, single-use bronchoscope.

Bronchoscopes are one of the most commonly-used instruments in hospitals, and they not only put patients at risk of infection if they are not cleaned properly but can come with a heavy price tag for institutions that reprocess them for use on other patients.

Hospitals that disinfect and reuse bronchoscopes pay anywhere from 21 percent to 155 percent more per instrument than if they had purchased a sterile, single-use bronchoscope, according to a new study.  The “real-world cost” for procedures with reusable bronchoscopes ranged from $281 to $803 for each bronchoscope and was comparable to or higher than the cost of sterile, single-use bronchoscopes, researchers found.

And those figures, according to the study, likely underestimate the total because costs associated with essential equipment such as leak testers, irrigation systems, automated endoscope reprocessors and drying cabinets were not included.

The study, “Managing Bronchoscope Quality and Cost: Results of a real-world study,” was conducted by Cori L. Ofstead, MSPH; Krystina M. Hopkins, MPH; John E. Eiland, RN, MS; Harry P. Wetzler, MD, MSPH. It builds on a related study last year, published in Chest Journal, that examined the effectiveness of the cleaning processes for reusable bronchoscopes.

Bronchoscopes, a type of endoscope, are delicate instruments that enable practitioners to see the airways to the lungs and perform interventions such as lung biopsies or removing pus and tumors. Reusable bronchoscopes also pose a high risk of cross-contamination. Sterile, single-use bronchoscopes can combat the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

In this new study, Dr. Ofstead and her team examined costs of acquisition, maintenance and repair, cleaning and other consumable reprocessing supplies. They also measured personnel time and wages for reprocessing bronchoscopes, as well as costs of having to reprocess cleaned bronchoscopes.

Want to learn more?

Enter your email below to download a copy of Dr. Ofstead’s study.

 

More Intensive Care Articles
Can Robotic Bronchoscopy Improve Diagnostic and Surgical Procedures?
Bronchoscopy Procedure
Two sets of findings, recently presented at the annual CHEST conference, generated results that warrant further evaluation in studies designed to yield comparative trials in advanced bronchoscopic techniques, researchers say.
Study: Sterile Single-Use Bronchoscopes Less Costly than Reusable Bronchoscopes
Supply Costs
New research quantifies how much more hospitals pay to disinfect and reuse bronchoscopes rather than purchasing single-use instruments and builds on a study last year examining the effectiveness of cleaning processes used for reusable bronchoscopes.
More From Single-Use Endoscopy
Bronchoscopy

Public Health

AABIP recommends that physicians not perform bronchoscopies on patients despite upper respiratory sampling being a primary method of diagnosing the novel virus. However, if it's warranted physicians should use a disposable bronchoscope to protect patients and staff.

Waste

Prevention Strategies

How can providers, manufacturers, and infection-prevention departments implement this shift without undue strain on their limited time and resources? We explore this issue in a series of posts guiding stakeholders through the process.

Doctor Holding Duodenoscope

Prevention Strategies

The FDA’s move to spur innovative designs to boost patient safety has stoked the market’s appetite for disposable scopes, but there are development hurdles.